Monday, April 23, 2012

Carcetti & O'Malley - The Stats Game


In the final blog post, I have decided to draw comparisons between fictional Mayor/Governor Tommy Carcetti with real-life Mayor/Governor Martin O’Malley. While David Simon argues O’Malley was only 'one of several inspirations' for Carcetti’s character, O’Malley rejects entirely the idea of links between himself and Carcetti, arguing 'I'm the antidote to The Wire.' Such cockiness, bordering on arrogance, is a line befitting of the fictional character Carcetti – perhaps this underlines the very link between the two hinted at by Peter Beilenson.

As real-life Mayor, O’Malley was responsible for the introduction of ‘stats culture’ to Baltimore Police Department. He was, in fact, widely praised for the ‘Compstat’ model he introduced, and for the accompanying statistical decreases in crime invoked (a 3,000 decrease in violent crimes in O'Malley's first year in office, for example). However, this is precisely the sort of policy David Simon seeks to criticize through The Wire. The culture of statistics is ultimately self-reinforcing, and sees Carcetti move from Mayor to Governor, with the same trajectory for O’Malley. Ultimately, O’Malley and his statistics can be seen as the embodiment of all that is wrong with society, in David Simon’s view.

No comments:

Post a Comment